| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:00 - Oct 12 with 6940 views | LeonWasGod |
And Cañas. But it's just clickbait sh*te posted by someone who doesn't know what they are talking about.
Worse 4 for me (considering a combination of value and how they performed):
- N'gog
- Tabanou
- Baston
- A. Ayew (2nd time)
Honorable mentions for:
Eder - could easily make top for on contribution, but cheaper than Baston so less of a waste of money!
Paloschi
Tiendalli
Narsingh
I've deliberately kept clear of devp squad players like Gorre who failed to make it. [Post edited 12 Oct 2018 12:01]
|  | |  |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:01 - Oct 12 with 6937 views | jack247 |
And on Canas. |  | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:05 - Oct 12 with 6920 views | EasternJack |
Only fat frank and Sanchez make my list from that lot.
Baston and Mesa have to picked ahead of Marvin and Canas in terms of disappointing transfers. |  |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:06 - Oct 12 with 6913 views | JackSomething |
Canas arrived on a free and left for free. Just for that, he shouldn't be included on a list like this. All that was lost on him was his wages. Compared to other transfers of recent years, that's almost good enough to consider him a successful signing.
As others have said, clickbait article anyway. Anyone not putting Bony and Andre Ayew (2nd signings for both) on that list doesn't know what they're talking about. |  |
| You know, Hobbes, some days even my lucky rocket ship underpants don't help. |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:08 - Oct 12 with 6907 views | LeonWasGod |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:05 - Oct 12 by EasternJack |
Only fat frank and Sanchez make my list from that lot.
Baston and Mesa have to picked ahead of Marvin and Canas in terms of disappointing transfers. |
Yep, I'd forgot about Mesa. I'd change my list but can't be fecked. | | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:09 - Oct 12 with 6906 views | Shaky |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:00 - Oct 12 by LeonWasGod |
And Cañas. But it's just clickbait sh*te posted by someone who doesn't know what they are talking about.
Worse 4 for me (considering a combination of value and how they performed):
- N'gog
- Tabanou
- Baston
- A. Ayew (2nd time)
Honorable mentions for:
Eder - could easily make top for on contribution, but cheaper than Baston so less of a waste of money!
Paloschi
Tiendalli
Narsingh
I've deliberately kept clear of devp squad players like Gorre who failed to make it. [Post edited 12 Oct 2018 12:01]
|
No Bony MK II?
On a price per league goals scored over a meaningful contract period for a striker, he sets a world record for sheer profligacy that I suspect will never be beaten. |  |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:21 - Oct 12 with 6883 views | LeonWasGod |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:09 - Oct 12 by Shaky |
No Bony MK II?
On a price per league goals scored over a meaningful contract period for a striker, he sets a world record for sheer profligacy that I suspect will never be beaten. |
Tough one isn't it. He's looking like shocking value, but only missed off in the (probably vain) hope that we might get something out of him this season. I'll add him to my honourable mention list.
I don't have Sanchez on their either as he did in (very small) spells show some class, but was in the wrong club, at the wrong time, under the wrong manager.
It's hard as we've had so much crap and wasted value in recent years. Can we have a top 20 instead of 4?  | | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:36 - Oct 12 with 6838 views | EasternJack |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:09 - Oct 12 by Shaky |
No Bony MK II?
On a price per league goals scored over a meaningful contract period for a striker, he sets a world record for sheer profligacy that I suspect will never be beaten. |
Radamel Falcao | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:40 - Oct 12 with 6828 views | somersetsimon |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:01 - Oct 12 by jack247 |
And on Canas. |
Criticising him for not scoring in his 35 appearances. As he was bought as a Leon replacement, I didn't think we expected any goals! |  | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:42 - Oct 12 with 6817 views | NeathJack |
Bony v2.0
A. Ayew v2.0
Baston
Mesa
£60m and absolutely no positive impact on the team whatsoever, just a massive drain on limited resources. |  | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:43 - Oct 12 with 6811 views | jack247 |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:36 - Oct 12 by EasternJack |
Radamel Falcao |
Torres had a good go at it at Chelsea | | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:43 - Oct 12 with 6811 views | Swanjaxs |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:01 - Oct 12 by jack247 |
And on Canas. |
Think it was Canas attitude that let him down more than ability to be honest, definitely could play a bit |  |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:46 - Oct 12 with 6803 views | hobo |
Don't know how they've included Canas. Their reasoning was because he failed to score a goal in 35 apps?!
Clucas got to be in there |  | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:51 - Oct 12 with 6789 views | swan65split |
Lets not forget the Black Panther..........the sleeping cat. |  | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 13:06 - Oct 12 with 6748 views | Professor |
Canas and Marvin were free or cheap (as was Tiendalli who did OK Imo) and made some contribution and at least made some effort . Baston, Mesa, Paloschi and Tabanou would be my 4, followed by Sanches, Clucas and Ayew.2 | | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 13:31 - Oct 12 with 6709 views | waynekerr55 |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:42 - Oct 12 by NeathJack |
Bony v2.0
A. Ayew v2.0
Baston
Mesa
£60m and absolutely no positive impact on the team whatsoever, just a massive drain on limited resources. |
Keeping Jenkins as DoF top of the list, no? |  |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 14:00 - Oct 12 with 6658 views | MrSwerve |
Emnes was a very decent option off the bench, always put in a shift when we needed an injection of life.
In no way does he deserve to be on that list, and he doesn't deserve half of the stick he gets (or got) on here. |  |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 14:06 - Oct 12 with 6646 views | Cooperman |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:42 - Oct 12 by NeathJack |
Bony v2.0
A. Ayew v2.0
Baston
Mesa
£60m and absolutely no positive impact on the team whatsoever, just a massive drain on limited resources. |
I can't argue with that. |  |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 14:10 - Oct 12 with 6640 views | Cooperman |
But so that this doesn't turn into a wave of negativity we should also consider the good signings of recent times; I put recent times as ten years.
Ashley Williams
Michu
Fabianski
Leon (2nd) | |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 14:44 - Oct 12 with 6599 views | Swan91 |
I actually liked Emnes... good substitute player... won many free kicks and ran so much. seemed like a player who never gave up. never faulted his effort. Always useful to have a player like that in the overall squad even if does't play often.
for me:
Sanches
mesa (i think he would do well under potter though.. more wrong place wrong time situation)
Tabanou
and even though I like Bony.. his second signing has to be classed as pretty bad.. | | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 15:23 - Oct 12 with 6537 views | 34dfgdf54 |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 12:09 - Oct 12 by Shaky |
No Bony MK II?
On a price per league goals scored over a meaningful contract period for a striker, he sets a world record for sheer profligacy that I suspect will never be beaten. |
He’s one of if not my favourite ever Swans players, but hard not to argue with that. It has been a disaster signing second time around. [Post edited 12 Oct 2018 15:24]
|  | | |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 17:14 - Oct 12 with 6425 views | MrSwerve |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 15:22 - Oct 12 by Ace_Jack |
tiendalli scored the winner against wigan away. Jack legend forever in my books  |
Tiendalli was half decent. Certainly as backup. | |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 17:45 - Oct 12 with 6374 views | monmouth |
The only conclusion I can draw from that list is that it was drawn up by Warwick and not Gary. |  |
| |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 18:30 - Oct 12 with 6327 views | WarwickHunt |
| The Four worst Swansea signings from the last 5 years.... on 17:45 - Oct 12 by monmouth |
The only conclusion I can draw from that list is that it was drawn up by Warwick and not Gary. |
Not guilty, guv.
Bony v2.0
A. Ayew v2.0
Baston
Clucas
In retrospect, at least N'Gog and Emnes had some comedy value. |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
