Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Saints Should Not Bring Back Fonte
Wednesday, 18th Jul 2018 07:45

Jose Fonte was a popular player amongst the Saints supporters during his 7 year stint at the club, however sentiment should not get in the way of realism.

Jose Fonte could lay claim to be one of the best signings that Southampton Football Club ever made, signed for a mere £1.2 million in January 2010 he went on to make almost 300 appearances for the club in all competitions and playing a key part in back to back promotions to return the club to the Premier League and a top six finish and successive European campaigns, no one can deny he played a key part in all of that and although at times I felt his form dipped he always seemed to be able to find that little extra from somewhere to confound his critics and keep going well into his 30's.

He left under a cloud though, after playing in Portugal's European Campionships winning side he returned to St Mary's a changed man with the papers full of a bid from Manchester United in the offing even before he had returned to the squad pre season.

Funnily enough his agent Jorge Mendes was a great mate of the new Manchester United manager Jose Mourinho and something stank about the deal, everyone seemed to be chasing money and even United themselves were said to have spoken to their new manager asking him why he was after Fonte.

Fonte's career at St Mary's could have and should have ended on a high, he could have knuckled down and if as he said he wanted to chase honours then why leave a club on the verge of a Wembley cup final, he could have pledged his future, stayed and he would certainly have been a much needed presence in the Saints defence that day against ironically the club who tried to sign him.

Instead with Saints leading 1-0 in the League Cup semi final first leg, with only days to go to the second leg he preferred to join West Ham for £8 million, a good bit of business for Saints if Virgil Van Dijk hadn't been injured days after, by this time though Fonte had been removed from the squad and preferred to kick his heals on the sidelines.

This was a sour end to what for all but the final few months had been a good fit for both club and player, but his behaviour at the end was both unprofessional and saddening, not to mention an insult to a club and it's supporters.

But that is not the reason why I feel that bringing him back to St Mary's is not a good idea, firstly there is his age factor, he will turn 35 in December.

Secondly there is just how little football he has played since leaving St Mary's and how poor his form has been, after joining West Ham he didn't exactly endear himself to the fans for his performances and he played only 24 Premier League games in 13 months.

The Hammers were relived when Chinese side Dalian Jifang offered to pay £ 5 million for the player in February of this year, but his stay in China would not be a good one, his first match saw his new side lose 8-0 to Shanghai SIPG and after his new side had lost 4 out of his first 6 matches, drawing the other 2 and shipping in 17 goals in the process, Fonte was dropped.

His final game for the club came back in May when he played in a 1-0 defeat ironically against Jiangsu Suning, Saints opponents in their second match on the Chinese tour.

Fonte played in all four games for Portugal in the World Cup, but the Portugese defence did not distinguish itself and went home with their reputation in tatters.

Thirdly there is the fact that Saints are now well served in the central defensive department, they have five players for that position and it is hard to see where Fonte would get in the team ahead of at last three of them.

There is a case for his leadership qualities in the side, but the reality is that his pace has gone, it is hard to see him getting through a Premier League season and the last 20 months performances for West Ham, Dalian Jifang and Portugal have not suggested that he is the player he was even two years ago.

So now is not the time for sentiment, it is time for reality and we have to ask what he would bring to the squad and the answer is very little and that is not enough to warrant bringing him back to St Mary's, even on a free transfer.

Get two free £10 bets by opening a new account at William Hill. Place an initial bet of a minimum of £10 and William Hill will give you two £10 bets. You must enter the promotional code ''F20'' when signing up as a new customer.

Photo: Action Images

Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.

derbydog added 07:57 - Jul 18
I agree that Saints shouldn’t be sentimental, but there is no need to be vindictive either. He is a free agent and provided his wages demands are reasonable why not take him back as a defensive coach, captain to what used to be known as the Reserves, and use his organisational skills which have been lacking at the back since he left. He might get a game if injuries or suspensions affect our first choice three centre backs.

A1079 added 08:45 - Jul 18
I wasn't aware there was a clamour for him to return, but that aside, we all make mistakes in life. None of us are perfect.


redwight added 10:27 - Jul 18
Terrible idea.

Consigliere added 13:57 - Jul 18
I don't think our players need lessons in shirt-tugging, do you?

KriSaint added 15:25 - Jul 18
How the hell did he keep his place in Portugals team??

underweststand added 21:26 - Jul 19
Few fans could honestly criticise Fonte for his contribution to our history since 2009.
He dropped a division to come to Saints (then in L1) -another good Pardew signing-
..and partnered a whole string of CB's all the way upto / and into the Prem. years.

I am still at a loss to understand how/why Claude Puel refused to use him after his return from the Euro Championships 2016, and it was likely CP who forced him out of the door . ..and onto WHam. Another illustration of a player who is consistant and reliable at one club and finds it all goes to pieces at the next club.

As for the situation now (?) ... I don't think that Saints /or Hughes will be considering him as a priority but I hope that he can find a club as he surely has a year or two left in him - even if it isn't at Prem.level.

Longer term--- if he has any coaching skills in him, Saints might look to bring him back in 2-3 years especailly as his one-time partner Radhi Jaidi has DAJFU with the U23's in the last couple of years, and may well move onto club management in the future.

elisawise added 07:34 - Jul 23
I have read through other blogs, but they are cumbersome and confusing. I hope you continue to have such quality articles to share with everyone!

vociduyef added 06:22 - Feb 20

You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 29 bloggers

Southampton Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2019