Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made 15:33 - Jan 16 with 1997 viewsSaintNick

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made


Your Vote:

You need to be logged in to vote on our site polls


Satisfying The Bloodlust Of The Masses In Peacetime

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 15:40 - Jan 16 with 1551 viewscocklebreath

Carrillo followed by Baz

Poll: Who is the biggest c*nt?

1
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 15:55 - Jan 16 with 1520 viewsDorsetIan

This has got to be clickbait, but I am biting!...

Including Sofiane Boufal in that list is an absolutely disgrace.

He is the best player to sign for Saints in the last ten years.

Poll: Would you welcome Oriol Romeu back?

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:12 - Jan 16 with 1479 viewsA1079

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 15:55 - Jan 16 by DorsetIan

This has got to be clickbait, but I am biting!...

Including Sofiane Boufal in that list is an absolutely disgrace.

He is the best player to sign for Saints in the last ten years.


Sports Republic
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:15 - Jan 16 with 1451 viewsfelly1

Carillo.
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:16 - Jan 16 with 1452 viewsshotters

How long have I got

Olivier Bernard?

If were including loan signings then Callum Davenport, possibly one of the worst defenders ive seen play for us, utterly shit and that's being kind
[Post edited 16 Jan 16:16]

Fail we may, sail we must

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:17 - Jan 16 with 1439 viewsfranniesTache

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:16 - Jan 16 by shotters

How long have I got

Olivier Bernard?

If were including loan signings then Callum Davenport, possibly one of the worst defenders ive seen play for us, utterly shit and that's being kind
[Post edited 16 Jan 16:16]


Carillo probably the worst, though not the worst player, that "honour" belongs to Lee Todd
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:21 - Jan 16 with 1428 viewsButty101

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:12 - Jan 16 by A1079

Sports Republic


Baz,Speedie, Dixon, Downes

Poll: Has the Ross Stewart deal already paid off as Nick says?

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:23 - Jan 16 with 1425 viewsGreenParkRanger

The full back - Todd I think who we signed with Paul Jones ?

Osher Williams wasn't any good if anyone else remembers him.
0
Login to get fewer ads

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:28 - Jan 16 with 1414 viewsInTimeAddedOn

Carthorse Carrillo for me đŸ« hence my ‘other player’ vote

Also a special mention for the Latvian Imants Bleidelis, a fellow member of the Carthorse Club. Amazingly, he made 106 International appearances, really not sure how

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:32 - Jan 16 with 1391 viewssaint22

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 15:40 - Jan 16 by cocklebreath

Carrillo followed by Baz


There is a few
But Carilla in recent memory
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:51 - Jan 16 with 1343 viewsgrumpy

Ali Dia
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 17:39 - Jan 16 with 1278 viewskingslandstand1

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 15:55 - Jan 16 by DorsetIan

This has got to be clickbait, but I am biting!...

Including Sofiane Boufal in that list is an absolutely disgrace.

He is the best player to sign for Saints in the last ten years.


If only for that goal against West Brom

Poll: Are you renewing your season ticket

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 17:44 - Jan 16 with 1270 viewsPatfromPoole

Relative to what they cost
.

1. Carillo
2. Downs
3. Mara
4. Vestergaard
5. Onuachu

Poll: Will Saints stay up?

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:00 - Jan 16 with 1234 viewsSaints76ER

Are we forgetting the utter embarrassment of signing Ali Dia in 1996. Bought by Souness after watching a video, believing him to be George Weah cousin. Dia couldn’t even kick a football. It was a free signing however.
In more recent times then has to be Carillo.
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:28 - Jan 16 with 1193 viewscocklebreath

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:00 - Jan 16 by Saints76ER

Are we forgetting the utter embarrassment of signing Ali Dia in 1996. Bought by Souness after watching a video, believing him to be George Weah cousin. Dia couldn’t even kick a football. It was a free signing however.
In more recent times then has to be Carillo.


Ali Dis cost us nothing, embarrassing yes but it made no difference. Spending 7/8 mill on damion downs is just horrific, if we do have scouts I hope that one was sacked

Poll: Who is the biggest c*nt?

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:29 - Jan 16 with 1194 viewsshotters

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 16:17 - Jan 16 by franniesTache

Carillo probably the worst, though not the worst player, that "honour" belongs to Lee Todd


I saw Lee Todd play in both games for Stockport against us in the league cup, pretty tidy for them

Pony at a higher level, bit like David Lee

I'd forgotten about Carrilo, which would be easy to do if he hadn't have cost 20 million

Fail we may, sail we must

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:32 - Jan 16 with 1185 viewsSaints76ER

Are we forgetting the utter embarrassment of signing Ali Dia in 1996. Bought by Souness after watching a video, believing him to be George Weah cousin. Dia couldn’t even kick a football. It was a free signing however.
In more recent times then has to be Carillo.
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:51 - Jan 16 with 1132 viewsshotters

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:32 - Jan 16 by Saints76ER

Are we forgetting the utter embarrassment of signing Ali Dia in 1996. Bought by Souness after watching a video, believing him to be George Weah cousin. Dia couldn’t even kick a football. It was a free signing however.
In more recent times then has to be Carillo.


Didn't see his "performance" in the league game against Leeds but I was at the Oxford league cup game at the manor ground when he was on the bench
Lots of ironic cheers when his name was read out

Fail we may, sail we must

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:52 - Jan 16 with 1130 viewssaint22

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 17:44 - Jan 16 by PatfromPoole

Relative to what they cost
.

1. Carillo
2. Downs
3. Mara
4. Vestergaard
5. Onuachu


Downs and MAra have to be up there
They are so similarly SH1TE yet we paid out how much on both....?!!
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 19:13 - Jan 16 with 1101 viewsTonyfromdk

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:52 - Jan 16 by saint22

Downs and MAra have to be up there
They are so similarly SH1TE yet we paid out how much on both....?!!


I think the title should be . Who is the worst signing we’ve ever made and spent the most money on.
There’s a few contenders for that.. One is from Italy and another from Argentina , I’m sure there is more
.
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 19:19 - Jan 16 with 1085 views1teeminants

For me Carillo definitely the worst but we’ve had some horrors.

Vergard Forren complete waste of money

Paul Moody. Awful

Richard Dryden see above


Juanmi


Lee Todd

Augustine Delgado

Kleber Chala


Imants Bledelis


Graham Potter

Damion Downs


Surprised none of these got a mention .
[Post edited 16 Jan 19:29]

Poll: Would you take an Fa Cup win if it meant relegation to the championship ?

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 20:20 - Jan 16 with 996 viewsfranniesTache

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 18:51 - Jan 16 by shotters

Didn't see his "performance" in the league game against Leeds but I was at the Oxford league cup game at the manor ground when he was on the bench
Lots of ironic cheers when his name was read out


I was at the league game Día played he actually came inches from scoring and wasn’t half as bad as people made out. I think the story has grown massively in size over the years, and if it wasn’t for the George weah bit he’d be completely forgotten

Also we never actually signed him, he was a trialist who’d been training with the squad and was put in the match day line up because we had a massive injury crisis.
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 20:43 - Jan 16 with 957 viewsgrumpy

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 20:20 - Jan 16 by franniesTache

I was at the league game Día played he actually came inches from scoring and wasn’t half as bad as people made out. I think the story has grown massively in size over the years, and if it wasn’t for the George weah bit he’d be completely forgotten

Also we never actually signed him, he was a trialist who’d been training with the squad and was put in the match day line up because we had a massive injury crisis.


He came on as substitute for Matt Le Tiss and was so bad was subbed himself against Leeds.
0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 21:09 - Jan 16 with 928 viewsshotters

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 20:20 - Jan 16 by franniesTache

I was at the league game Día played he actually came inches from scoring and wasn’t half as bad as people made out. I think the story has grown massively in size over the years, and if it wasn’t for the George weah bit he’d be completely forgotten

Also we never actually signed him, he was a trialist who’d been training with the squad and was put in the match day line up because we had a massive injury crisis.


He didn't get on the pitch for the Oxford game

I found some footage of the highlights of the game on YouTube

Nice goal from Richard Dryden, I see he been mentioned on this thread but he was a cheap signing on the recommendation of Terry Cooper and whilst he wasn't great, at least you could see he was trying his best

Van Gobble was playing in that game too, looked absolutely hopeless from the highlights

Fail we may, sail we must

0
Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 21:17 - Jan 16 with 917 viewsshotters

Who Is The Worst Signing Saints Have Ever Made on 19:19 - Jan 16 by 1teeminants

For me Carillo definitely the worst but we’ve had some horrors.

Vergard Forren complete waste of money

Paul Moody. Awful

Richard Dryden see above


Juanmi


Lee Todd

Augustine Delgado

Kleber Chala


Imants Bledelis


Graham Potter

Damion Downs


Surprised none of these got a mention .
[Post edited 16 Jan 19:29]


I see your Richard Dryden

I'll raise with Scott Marshall

2games, 2 own goals

I remember when we signed him from Arsenal he was pretty highly rated

Alan Bennett was very poor too

Fail we may, sail we must

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026